4756 Buck Springs Rd.
Pinetop, AZ 85935
Shelby Teel
White Mountain Realtor
ST
Below you will find my past sales and customer reviews.
2019 Sales
1880 S Canyon Ridge Trail
Show Low, AZ 85901
Subdivision: Sierra Pines
Represented: Seller
Days on Market: 70
Listed for: $460,000
Sales Price: $450,000
6962 Kings High Rd
Show Low, AZ 85901
Subdivision: Linden Unsubdivided
Represented: Seller
Days on Market: 7
Listed for: $330,000
Sales Price: $360,000
​
Seller Review:
Working with Shelby was a great experience for our family while selling our house. She went out of her way to help us get it ready to sell, had excellent pictures taken by a photographer, and was always attentive throughout the whole process. She always listened to our concerns and was as quickly responsive as she possibly could be. We learned very valuable things from her that we hadn't known about in the past for selling or buying a home. If we decide to come back to the White Mountains in the future, we know who we will be in contact with. Great job and thanks!
2600 W Old Linden Rd
Show Low, AZ 85901
Subdivision: Fools Hollow Lake Resort
Represented: Seller
Days on Market: 2
Listed for: $179,850
Sales Price: $180,000
2541 Village Court
Pinetop, AZ 85935
Subdivision: The Village
Represented: Seller
Days on Market: 6
Listed for: $218,850
Sales Price: 215,000
​
Seller Review:
​I am a lender and understand the importance of working with a good real estate agent. We had a very smooth transaction and she kept us informed every step of the way. And did I say, sold my house in less than 10 days! Thank you Shelby!
1531 Ox Bow
Lakeside, AZ 85929
Subdivision: Lakeside Unsubdivided
Represented: Seller
Days on Market: 2
Listed for: $274,850
Sales Price: $274,850
Lot 6 Porter Mnt Rd
Lakeside, AZ 85929
Subdivision: Lakeside Unsubdivided
Represented: Buyer
Sales Price: $60,000
​
Buyer Review:
​Shelby is a delight to work with! With her extensive knowledge of the area, she was able to help us buy the property that we have been dreaming about for years! Very professional, knowledgeable, and stayed on top of the transaction from beginning to end. She also went above and beyond her normal real estate duties to make sure that we had all the information and contacts that we needed to make our dream come true. We highly recommend Shelby Hall for all your real estate needs.
4811 Sweeping Vista Dr
Pinetop, AZ 85935
Subdivision: Pinetop Lakes CC
Represented: Buyer
Listed for: $399,850
Sales Price: $385,000
7137 Palomino Dr.
Pinetop, AZ 85935
Subdivision: Pinetop Lakes CC
Represented: Buyer
Sales Price: $59,000
​
Buyer Review:
​We weren't sure on what type of house/cabin we wanted, so Shelby was very willing to show us places within our price range. She was very patient with us during the 5 or 6 months we couldn't find the place we wanted. We decided to look at lots and Shelby was very diligent in finding us many to look at and when we finally found one we liked, she was more than helpful with hooking us up with water well and septic tank contractors. When that didn't work out, she again proceeded to find us more lots to view. Finally, we found one that had everything in place, she gave us 5 or 6 reputable builders to call to get quotes to build our home. Shelby was very responsible, dedicated, courteous, and honest with us throughout our year long search. I would highly recommend her to anyone who is looking for a home/cabin in the White Mountain area.
4505 Stone Pine Dr.
Pinetop, AZ 85935
Subdivision: Stone Pine
Represented: Seller
Days on Market: 385
Listed for: $220,000
Sales Price: $210,000
4886 Mallard Cir.
Pinetop, AZ 85935
Subdivision: Pinetop Lakese CC
Represented: Seller
Days on Market: 547
Listed for: $135,000
Sales Price: $100,000
2860 Sports Village #46
Pinetop, AZ 85935
Subdivision: Sports Village
Represented: Buyer
Sales Price: $145,500
1501 1st Ave.
Eager, AZ 85925
Subdivision: Table Top Mnt.
Represented: Buyer
Sales Price: $135,000
5957 D Street
Lakeside, AZ 85929
Subdivision: Wagon Wheel Park
Represented: Buyer
Sales Price: $67,500
2800 S White Mountain Rd.
Show Low, AZ 85901
Subdivision: Timberline RV Park
Represented: Seller
Sales Price: $50,900
6901 Queens High Rd, Show Low
Sold for: $139,000
Represented: Buyers
5767 Courgar Crt
Pinetop, AZ 85935
Subdivision: Pinetop CC Mobile Homes
Represented: Seller
Sales Price: $75,500
2018 Sales
540 E Owens, Show Low
Sold for: $184,000
Represented: Sellers
Description:
Living is easy in this inviting, generously spacious residence with panoramic views from every window. The unique floor plan encompasses three nice sized bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms and an open kitchen that features Stainless Steel appliances that then flows into the dining/living room. The expansive living room features new hardwood floors, vaulted ceilings and a sky light that opens up to a newly added Arizona room. The oversized 2 car garage offers a storage room, built in shelves, heating and the third bathroom; ideal for those who love to work in the garage. New metal roof added in 2015. Never feel afraid, as this home is on an alarm system and is less than a minute from the Show Low Police & Fire Department. Perfect for anyone, this home is ideally located in the heart of Show Low.
6469 Buck Springs Place
Subdivision: Pinetop Country Club
Represented: Buyer
Sales Price: $495,000
4805 Deep Forest Dr. Pinetop
Subdivision: The Timbers
Represented: Buyer
Sold for: $328,000
​
Represented: Seller
Sold for: $340,000
Description:
​
Costumer Review:
I had the pleasure to work with this young realtor. Being young she's got a fire underneath her which made it is a pleasure to work with her, she went out of her way to ensure the property always looks good and was in shape to show. She took the initiative to take care of surprises IE fallen tree that her husband and her took care of for me. She is extremely professional always kept me in the loop and suggested strategies. The one thing I failed to do which she highly recommended and at the time I did not have the extra money. Was to go ahead and have the house pre inspected in order to not have surprises at closing. If I only would have listened to her I would have saved myself of thousands of dollars. I could have made the corrections for less than than $2,000. At closing I had to spend $15,000 to fix problems that I was unaware of. She is wise passed her years. And I highly recommend her to anybody that's buying or selling. But I would highly listen to her advise because even though she's young she has ran into these situations in other sales. 12 thumbs up for this young realtor. Thank you again Shelby for all your hard work and your commitment and your professionalism and it was a pleasure working with you thank you John
5131 Charro Way Pinetop
Subdivision: Pinetop Lakes Country Club
Represented: Seller
Sales Price: $325,000
Description:
Centrally located in the Pinetop Lakes Country Club, this beautiful home has it all. Large and open great room which leads to an enormous kitchen and laundry/office room, a massive upstairs loft that could be a potential 4th bedroom or game room, a large back deck that over looks a nicely landscaped fenced in yard and an over-sized two car garage with an abundance of storage. Enjoy the four seasons the White Mountains has to offer and call this house your home!
5254 Drifting Snow Loop, Pinetop
Land
Sold for Over Listed Price: $35,500
Represented: Sellers
Description:
Peaceful and leveled 0.28 acres situated in a cul-de-sac within the Pinetop Lakes Country Club! Enjoy Rec Center privileges (workout facility, pool, spa, games, etc.), hiking, fishing and everything else the beautiful White Mountains has to offer. At such a great price, this lot won't last long. Call today for more information!
6918 Aces High - Show Low
Represented: Buyer
Sales Price: $164,900
Buyer Review:
Our entire family just fell in love with Shelby! She is so personable and such a joy to work with! We kept her running trying to find the PERFECT home. Anytime something new popped up that fit our criteria, she was sending it our way and making plans to show it to us right away. Once we found our home, the entire process of purchasing our home went so smoothly because she was right there every step of the way! We really felt she cared about our interests. We will be recommending Shelby to anyone we know that is purchasing/selling a home. Thank you Shelby for all your hard work!!!
![untitled-0040_HDR[1].jpg](https://static.wixstatic.com/media/2f2f04_378658aa29c944e5a41038436011d6ab~mv2_d_2733_1822_s_2.jpg/v1/crop/x_4,y_0,w_2724,h_1822/fill/w_462,h_309,al_c,q_80,usm_0.66_1.00_0.01,enc_auto/untitled-0040_HDR%5B1%5D.jpg)
7857 Lakewood Dr.
Subdivision: Pinetop Country Club
Represented: Buyer & Seller
Sales Price: $375,000
This beautiful home sold in less than 12 hours!
Description:
​Here is your cabin high in the Ponderosa Pine Trees! Located on a quiet street in Pinetop Country Club, this picturesque cabin is perfect for your White Mountain retreat. The floor to ceiling windows in the living room paints a picture of the top of the pines while also bringing in natural light that flows throughout the home. The maintenance free deck overlooks 0.60 acres of natural landscaping. Special features include: new granite counter tops in kitchen and bathrooms, new stainless steel appliances, new ceiling fans and lighting in each room, 3 year old roof, maintenance free siding and mostly furnished. Within walking distance of Jackson Lake and only a minutes drive from Forest Service Rds that will take you anywhere on the mountain. Look no further and claim your cabin in the woods!
3699A Crown Dancer
Subdivision: Quality Hill
Represented: Seller
Sales Price: $202,000
Sellers Review:
Excellent professional service. A real pleasure to work with her. Shelby was attentive and responsive to all our questions. Would give her the highest recommendation.
2768A Sports Village Loop
Subdivision: Sports Village #3
Represented: Buyer
Sales Price: $117,000
1110 W. Valley View Dr. Taylor
Sold for: $78,000
Represented: Buyer
​
Customer Review:
Shelby dealt seamlessly with many issues add extended escrow. She had solutions before I even heard of the various problems. She is really a bright elegant beautiful person.
Lot 851 Ranch of the White Mountains
Land
Represented: Seller
Sold for: $20,000
Description:
​Secluded and peaceful 18.01 acres of land with highway frontage in Concho, AZ. Well is installed. From wildlife to panoramic views; this property will not disappoint!
2764 Mason Ridge Rd. Taylor
Represented: Buyer
Sold for: $228,000
6367 Christmas Tree Circle, Pinetop
Subdivision: Pinetop Lakes Plaza 1
Represented: Seller
Sold for: $194,000
Description:
Adorable 2 bedroom 2 bath home situated in the heart of Pinetop Lakes Country Club. This home features new paint throughout interior & exterior, T&G ceilings, new metal roof, new wrap around porch that also leads to a gazebo and a fully wooded fenced in back yard; perfect for backyard BBQ's and gatherings. Enjoy everything that the Pinetop Lakes Rec Center has to offer from only a few steps away! Skiing, hiking, fishing, biking and much more within a short distance. This home won't stay on the market long, hurry and bring your offers!
6043 Paradise Pine Rd
Sold for: $249,000
Represented: Buyer
8476 Basalt, Show Low
Land
Sold for: $15,000
Represented: Seller
Description:
Delightful, leveled, nicely treed, 1.11 lot located in the White Mountain Lakes Subdivision. This lot is perfect for any individual who is looking for a nice lot in the WML subdivision to build on. This lot is only half a mile from the WML's golf course and clubhouse!
5243 Drifting Snow Loop, Pinetop
Sold Full Price for: $208,000
Represented: Sellers
Description:
Delightful and relaxing home situated in Pinetop Lakes Country Club! This inviting and comfortable 2 bedroom 2 bathroom home spans 1,296 square feet on a beautifully landscaped lot. Spacious 2 car garage with shelving, garage vac, work bench and a cedar closet is perfect for any handyman. Other special highlights include: metal roof, two inviting decks and a very well maintained and clean home. With this house you not only get to enjoy everything the White Mountains has to offer but also, you will have Rec Center privileges. All you need is your toothbrush, as this home comes furnished!
​
Costumer Review:
Shelby was very neat in her appearance. We felt she was knowledgeable. She took her time when she came to list the property and also to inventory the furnishings. She has a very nice personality.
1125 Deer Park Rd. Show Low
Represented: Buyer
Sales Price: $125,000
2800 S White Mountain Rd Show Low
Subdivision: Timberline
Represented: Buyer
Sales Price: $46,600
.jpg)
6532 Mark Twain Dr. Pinetop
Subdivision: Pinetop Lakes Country Club
Represented: Buyer
Sales Price: $308,500
Buyer Review:
Shelby does a great job as a Realtor. She is very responsive to phone calls and emails. She listens and if she doesn't know an answer she will find out. I have referred her to other people. She really works hard.
590 S 1st Place, Show Low
Sold for: $153,625
Represented: Sellers
Description:
Charming three bedroom, two bathroom manufactured home in Timber Ridge, Show Low, AZ. Vaulted ceilings, updated floor plan, one of the few with a two car garage! Air conditioning. Centrally located in Show Low, close to shopping, schools, recreation, medical service, etc.
3802 Porter Creek Ln - Lakeside
Subdivision: Porter Creek
Represented: Buyer
Sales Price: $175,500
Buyer Review:
She is a beautiful person who will go far. In spite of her youth she is very much an adult and very professional!
TBD CR 3082, Vernon
Land
Represented: Buyer
Sold for: $26,000
5336 Grey Wolf Dr. Lakeside
Subdivision: Wolf Pines
Represented: Buyer
Sales Price: $194,900
5330 Branding Iron Loop, Pinetop
Subdivision: Pinetop Lakes Country Club
Represented: Buyer
Sales Price: $208,500
1320 Skyline Rd, Snowflake
Subdivision: Valley View Estates
Represented: Buyer
Sales Price: $215,000
​
4179 Yellow Jacket Lane, Pinetop
Subdivision: Pinetop Lakes Mobile Homes
Represented: Seller
Sold before coming on the market: $61,000
Description:
This 1,536 square foot manufactured home features 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, a cozy wood stove and a covered deck that is situated on a beautifully landscaped lot. Within the property you will find yourself among many different trees, including: Ponderosa, Oak, Aspen, Peach, Cherry, Apple and Pear. Not only will you have access to everything the great White Mountains has to offer; you will also have a membership to the Rec Center; pool, spa, workout facility and much more! You can have so much for such a low price, call today for a showing!
2678 Juniper Circle, Pinetop
Subdivision: Mountain Pines Estate
Represented: Buyer
Sold for: $225,000
​
Costumer Review:
She is very experienced on local market conditions. We explained the style and desired location of the home we were looking to buy and she found multiple listings that fit our needs. She was professional, efficient and 100% accurate on all the paperwork needed to complete the purchase.
501 N 9th Dr, Show Low
Sold for: $112,500
Represented: Buyers
​
Costumer Review:
Shelby not only got our home sold in less than two weeks, but she helped us to get it sold above asking price. In addition, she helped us find our new home very quickly. Overall she is very friendly, easy to work with and very familiar with the Show Low/Pinetop area.
5720 Spruce, Pinetop
Subdivision: Mountain Pines Estates
Represented: Seller
Sold for: $219,000
Description:
Beautiful Mountain Pines Estates Townhome. Remodeled improvements to include, laminate wood texture flooring, enlarged deck completed with maintenance free trex type decking. The unfinished original construction options for a loft and 4th bedroom were constructed increasing the sq ft by approx. 400 sq ft. Ideal location provides wonderful views from the living area and deck. Being sold completely furnished and is move-in ready! Mountain Pines Estates is the only townhome or condo community in Pinetop that enjoys Pinetop Lakes Recreation Center privileges providing access to swimming, tennis, exercise facility, racquetball, clubhouse and more. A must see!
1000 E Owens, Show Low
Sold Over Listed Price for: $188,500
Represented: Sellers
Description:
Recently remodeled in 2013, this 3 bedroom 3 bathroom home has it all! Spacious home that is centrally located in Show Low has two Master Suites, guest bedroom, office/fourth bedroom and an added-on room for extra entertainment which spans a massive 1956 square feet that sits on .36 acres! More features include: granite counter tops throughout kitchen and bathrooms, new laminate and carpeted flooring, landscaped front yard, four Apple tree's in front yard, two Pear tree's in backyard, storage shed and it also backs up to the Nikolaus Park – perfect for dog owners! Call today, as this gem will not stay on the market long!
​
Costumer Review:
Shelby is amazing! She helped us sell our home and buy a new one in such a very smooth transition/process. She always kept us in the loop throughout our experience and explained with such patience as well when we didn't understand something. Shelby took time out of her busy schedule to meet with us when we needed her and helped us to be more optimistic during a very stressful time. I appreciate all that she did for us!
2362 E Rainbow Lane, Pinetop
Subdivision: Pine Lake Meadow
Sold for: $188,000
Represented: Seller
Description:
Incredible location - great room windows overlook White Mountain Summers Homes and the Arizona Room backs to Pineridge with peaceful views, views, views all around. Small subdivision where the HOA owns the private lake and clubhouse for owner's enjoyment. 17x8 Arizona room with 2 walls of windows overlooking the trees. Furnished.
3558 W Bermuda, Pinetop
Sold for Full Price: $198,000
Represented: Sellers
Description:
Peaceful and homey cabin located in the Pinetop Country Club area! This charming home features 3 bedrooms 2 baths with vaulted T&G ceilings, covered and uncovered decks, gas fireplace with stone fascia, and great room. This cabin is situated in the Pinetop Lakes Mountain Homes subdivision that allows access to the Rec Center which includes a clubhouse, pool, spa and workout facility. Not only does this home offer everything a person needs, it also comes completely furnished!
590 S 1st Place, Show Low
Sold for: $130,000
Represented: Buyer
1341 N 26th Dr. Show Low
Subdivision: Fools Hollow Lake
Represented: Buyer
Sales Price: $103,000
231 Timber Ridge Loop Show Low
Subdivision: Timber Ridge
Represented: Buyer
Sales Price: $195,000
​
Customer Review:
Shelby is an amazing realtor. From showing the property to walking me through the entire process start to finish. She kept in touch after closing to ensure an easy transition into my new home. Five star recommendation all around.
1490 Walnut Lane, Lakeside
Subdivision: Lakeside Unsubdivided
Represented: Buyer
Sales Price: $223,000
​
Customer Review:
Shelby went above and beyond as our realtor. She made the proceeds easy for us, and helped us find the perfect home for our family.
5400 Concho Ocho, Snowflake
Represented: Seller
Sold for: $325,900
Description:
Two homes for the price of one on 243.7 acres!! This property includes a gorgeous 4 bedroom 2 bath 2560 square foot home as well as a 3 bedroom 2 bath 1,188 square foot guest house/second home. The property is fully fenced with 4 different fenced in pastures. Owners are in the process of installing a hot tub and hardwood floors throughout main house. From wildlife including: Antelope, Mule Deer, Elk, Coyotes and more to panoramic views in all directions! Wow, what else could someone ask for?
​
Costumer Review:
Shelby is an amazing realtor! She was patient with us and found us the perfect home with everything we were looking for. Not only did she find us our dream home but sold our other property! She made it so smooth, and I never had to worry! I would recommend her to anyone, and have!!!
1856 Simpson Well, Linden
Represented: Buyer
Sold for: $174,900
![DJI_0001_HDR[1].jpg](https://static.wixstatic.com/media/2f2f04_c8769a308b9b48b595a7a2e77f507f42~mv2_d_3988_2989_s_4_2.jpg/v1/crop/x_0,y_157,w_3988,h_2676/fill/w_462,h_310,al_c,q_80,usm_0.66_1.00_0.01,enc_auto/DJI_0001_HDR%5B1%5D.jpg)
858 Larson Rd. Lakeside, AZ
Subdivision: Lakeside Unsubdivided
Represented: Seller
Sales Price: $275,000
​
Costumer Review:
Shelby did an outstanding job on the sale of my home. She went above and beyond in providing services and assistance in the sale and handling post sale inquiries. I would highly recommend Shelby and I dont take my recommendations lightly, being in the real estate investment business myself. You can count on her doing what she says she will do!
​
2951 W Villa Loop, Show Low
Subdivision: The Retreat Villas @ Bison Crossing
Represented: Buyer
Sales Price: $260,000
​